Notes from a BlackBerry Newby

Capturing the Journey into the World of the BlackBerry

Archive for October 2009

BB AppWorld and iPhone App Store

with one comment

Just started spending a bit more time on the BB AppWorld.

At first approximation, the AppWorld is like the iPhone App Store.  And, from that perspective, I’d very much like to be able to use it to find out what I have on my BB.  It is quite confusing / distracting / cumbersome that the AppWorld tells me that I’ve archived Slacker 2.0.2, when I have installed Slacker 2.0.49.

It is very nice that RIM/BB does not force me to use the RIM AppWorld, but the AppWorld client should show me everything that’s in my device, not just what I installed via the RIM store.  The beauty of the BB infrastructure is that it knows that… but I don’t want to go to Options->Advanced->Applications and do a visual diff/aggregate.

And, while fixing that, I’d like to know what version of the AppWorld client I’m running from the application.  Pretty please!

Keep the good work…

Written by pelegri

October 31, 2009 at 10:57 am

Posted in Uncategorized

What is the Role for BB’s Web Signals?

leave a comment »

Just bumped into the BB web signal at the BB site. Where are they supposed to fit in the BB ecosystem? And why are they not in the AppWorld?

Are they an evolutionary dead-end?  A brand-new development?

They seem to me they could be a handy, quick, way for content providers to push information to the BB users via BB push.  The content is all relatively homogeneous and one could write a pretty nice generic WebSignal client that everybody could reuse to generate content (via RSS/Atom).  Then everybody reuses the same machinery and benefits from updates to the common client.

Right now (as tested by the CBC News and from the docs I can see), this is an icon that then launches the browser.  Which is emphasizing the weakest part of the BB platform!

Written by pelegri

October 31, 2009 at 10:36 am

Posted in Uncategorized

Fixing the Facebook App

leave a comment »

The Facebook app for my tour was a disappointment. Facebook seems a natural match for the Blackberries: the content is fairly well structured and can fit well within the small screen of the BBs. The keyboard makes for quick input and push should provide fast delivery of friends notifications without battery drain

But the UI for the BB was substantially inferior to that of the iPhone and the notification delivery was not very good

I think RIM needs a few Apps that are better on the BB than in any other phone and FB can be the one

I’d open source the FB App – at the least the client but ideally the server side too. Then welcome bug fixes and be very transparent about the whole development, and, when people want to contribute changes be receptive. And make this App the prototype for other high quality Apps on the BB.

And make it ASL; at this srtage of the Adoption game you want people to borrow this code to make as many other high quality Apps as possible

Written by pelegri

October 24, 2009 at 11:39 am

Posted in Uncategorized

Tagged with

Facebook Clients – BB Tour or iPod Touch

with 2 comments

Running entry – will update as I discover issues / learn new things

Strong Disclaimer: I’m not a regular user of FaceBook, but I’ll try to use the two a bit to get a reasonable feeling about how they work

WebSite

The new RIM home page for the Tour is an improvement, but I can’t figure out from there basic things (like the push behavior).

Note that the BlackBerry page at Facebook still likes 1.6 as the latest version, not 1.7.

Facebook pages/sites/comments

The Facebook page for the BB app claims 10M users and 291K.  16 of my friends use it.  Rating is 3.2/5 on +1800 reviews, but the latest reviews are much better.  Note same complaints about not getting notified of latest version (see below).  I also had the same issue as reported there on battery consumption.  And ditto about not getting notifications (may be a problem with overloads/deployments, we will see)

The Facebook page for the iPhone app claims 15M users (and 532K fans). 44 of my friends use it. Rating is 3.8/5 on 3940 reviews.  All recent reviews are 5.

Random numbers: iPhone-3G has 662K fans; iPhone has 375K fans; iPhone, 3G has 241K fans.  iPod Touch has 243K fans.

Presentation

I like the iPhone better.  Easier to see what’s there, easier to select.  Easier to do a better job because there is more real-estate to play with, and it is natural to just click on the screen rather than having to move around with the trackball, but things like the font-size are better on the iPhone and there is not a good reason for that.

Note, I have an old G1 8GB iPod Touch (MA623LL), running 3.1.2 (7D11).  I’m going to try it also on my kid’s G2 iPod Touch.

My son is a regular and heavy FaceBook user. I showed him the BB interface and he was confused; it didn’t match his mental model of what the home page was, etc.  I’m going to do the same experiment tomorrow with the iPhone client.

Physical Screen

ipod Screen size – 320 × 480 px, 3.5 in (89 mm), 2:3 aspect ratio, 262,144-color LCD at 163 pixels per inch (ppi)

Tour Screen size – 480 x 360 px, Half VGA+, 2.6 in (diagonal), roughly 2:3, 65K-color LCD. ?? ppi (~210 ppi?)

Push Events

I was expecting the BB to get events pushed automatically.  Maybe it is a user configuration? Maybe I didn’t generate the right notification (I changed my status).

Actually the BB didn’t notice the change as fast as the iPod did.

Chat

iPod has it, BB does not. See no chat.

Others – iTunes AppStore vs BB AppStore

My BB came with the FaceBook app installed and it automatically upgraded it, but note that several folks are complaining that they have registered for notifications of upgrades and instead have to get the info from CrackBerry.  The lack of coordination across the different release mechanisms is an issue and leads to unsatisfaction w/ customers.  See FaceBook 1.7 announcement @CB, complains 1, 2,

The iPhone/iPod guys have a much better story on this.

I am sorry to say that!  I’m am usually against Apple’s policy of forcing me to go through their AppStore for upgrades, but, in this aspect, there is a benefit.  A solution may be to insist to BB partners to release first to the BB AppStore, then to their sites – and do a better job with the leaks – they are not helping.

Written by pelegri

October 17, 2009 at 10:43 pm

BB ideas – Storm as USB monitor

leave a comment »

I can use a BBerry as an attached mass device although I’ve not done much with that so far, except copy/edit content manually, but it works fine.

I’ve wanted one of those secondary small monitors for a bit (like the mimo), to use as a dedicated widget screen.  They connect to the laptop via a USB, some have a touchscreen, some do not…

What if the Storm(2) supported that?

Written by pelegri

October 12, 2009 at 4:48 pm

Posted in Uncategorized

Tagged with

Applications and BlackBerry

leave a comment »

(This is a post in progress.  Should it be a page instead of a post?  Multiple Posts?  So far, it is just a collection of links)

Some random links on the status of Application Store / Development for the BlackBerry.

The iPhone AppStore

Written by pelegri

October 11, 2009 at 8:47 am

Posted in Uncategorized

How to explain BBerries to a non-BB user?

leave a comment »

As a BB newbie, I’m interested in both the value proposition of the BBs and how people discover that value.  And, from my personal experience and what I see in posts, getting that value across is a challenge.

Check out the comments at these two posts at Engadget: RIM posts new BlackBerry widget APIs, dev kit and BlackBerry Messenger 5 now available, we go hands-on

There is a clear value when the user is inside a community of users that are all using BBs; an extreme case is in a corporate account, where the BB-bubble includes the intranet, but if that is not the case – like me right now, where neither my company nor my family are using BBerries – the value is much less clear.  And, if you want to grow virally, you need the benefits to be evident to non-users.

Perhaps one area to focus is family dynamics.  A family could be a good wedge point into the market.  Take my case, there are 4 of us; one in college away from home, one in HS with two adults.  We talk, mostly SMS for the son/daugher, to each other all the time and I’d be willing to spend some $$s to get more of us on a BBerry, but plans like the buy-1, get 1 free didn’t help me as all the people in my family have a phone already and their upgrade dates are all different.

Me-thinks breaking through this viral dynamics is the main (not the only one, but the main) challenge to the BBerries right now…

Written by pelegri

October 10, 2009 at 3:51 pm

Posted in Uncategorized